Audio Version (09:25)
“If I don’t get this right, they’ll realise I’m not good enough.” Does that sound familiar? That’s where perfectionism becomes exhausting: a mistake stops being something you’ve done and starts feeling like proof of who you are.
Someone once told me, “I can’t follow you because you make spelling mistakes.” It’s an interesting expectation, isn’t it? Of course, accuracy matters, and we should take responsibility for errors. But expecting someone to never make a mistake means expecting them to stop being human.
It also raises a question: if we find other people’s imperfections that difficult to tolerate, how do we treat ourselves when we get something wrong?
Perfectionism can look like high standards, ambition or attention to detail. Underneath, however, there may be a fear of criticism, rejection or shame.
In today’s article, we’re exploring the needs perfectionism is trying to meet, why mistakes can feel so threatening, and what chasing perfect could be costing your physical and mental health.
In the extended YouTube version, I also discuss how to loosen the grip of perfectionism. You can watch it here.
What Need Is Perfectionism Filling?
There’s a difference between wanting to do something well and feeling that you cannot afford to get it wrong. One allows room for learning. The other turns every mistake into a potential verdict on who you are.
Perfectionism can be an attempt to meet needs such as:
Acceptance: “If I’m perfect, people will like me.”
Safety: “If I don’t make mistakes, nobody can criticise me.”
Control: “If I get everything right, nothing bad will happen.”
Self-worth: “If I achieve enough, I’ll finally feel good enough.”
You might not consciously think those things. Instead, you notice yourself checking an email repeatedly, agonising over a decision or replaying something you said hours earlier.
The task might be finished, but you don’t feel able to leave it alone. What you’re looking for is reassurance that you haven’t given anyone a reason to judge you.
Unfortunately, perfectionism cannot provide that guarantee.
Where Did You Learn You Had to Be Perfect?
For some people, the pattern starts in childhood. Perhaps achievements received plenty of attention, while mistakes brought criticism, comparison or disappointment. You may have learned that approval depended on performing well.
Sometimes the messages were subtle. You brought home a good result, and the first question was why it wasn’t better. Over time, you learned to focus on what was missing rather than what you had achieved.
For others, perfectionism can become part of a response to trauma or an unpredictable environment. Being exceptionally careful, helpful or well behaved may have felt like a way to avoid someone’s anger.
That doesn’t mean everyone who experiences perfectionism has a trauma history. Temperament, school, workplace expectations and wider social pressures can also contribute. But it is worth asking: “When did making a mistake start feeling so risky?”
Why Your Brain Can Treat Mistakes as a Threat
If you have learned to associate mistakes with humiliation, rejection or punishment, getting something wrong may feel like more than an inconvenience. You may anticipate what comes next: criticism, conflict or being seen as inadequate.
That interpretation can trigger a stress response. Your heart might race, your stomach tighten, or your thoughts become consumed by what someone will think. Research has found that people high in self-critical perfectionism can be particularly reactive to situations involving possible failure, criticism or loss of control.
This doesn’t mean your brain treats every typo exactly like a physical emergency. It means the meaning you attach to a mistake can make it feel threatening.
You might know logically that one imperfect presentation won’t ruin your career. Emotionally, however, you feel exposed. Checking, overpreparing or avoiding the task then brings temporary relief, making those behaviours tempting again next time.
The Cost to Your Mental and Physical Health
Living under constant internal scrutiny is exhausting. There is always something to improve, something you should have anticipated or someone doing better than you.
Even success may provide little satisfaction. You reach the target, briefly feel relieved, then raise the standard. Instead of enjoying what you’ve achieved, you start worrying about maintaining it.
Perfectionism, particularly when it involves harsh self-criticism and concern about mistakes, is associated with anxiety, depression and other mental health difficulties. These are associations, rather than a prediction that every perfectionist will become unwell.
The pressure can affect you physically too. Stress can involve headaches, muscle tension and stomach problems, while difficulty switching off may interfere with sleep. You may also work through breaks or put off rest because you haven’t “earned” it yet.
The irony is that exhaustion makes concentration harder. You become more likely to make mistakes, then criticise yourself for struggling.
Perfectionism Can Stop You Doing Things
Perfectionism doesn’t always look productive. Sometimes it looks like procrastination, indecision, or never quite being ready.
You don’t apply for the role because you cannot meet every requirement. You keep rewriting rather than publishing, or avoid a difficult conversation because you haven’t found the perfect words.
As I was editing this in a hotel lobby, I overheard someone being asked whether he plays golf. His response? “I don’t do things I’m not good at.”
One comment doesn’t tell us whether he’s a perfectionist, but it captures a rule many of us live by: if I can’t do something well, I won’t do it at all. Yet becoming good at something usually involves being fairly bad at it first.
Doing only what we already do well means missing opportunities to learn, discover new interests, and have fun without needing to achieve anything.
What looks like a lack of motivation may actually be fear of getting it wrong. Opportunities pass, confidence shrinks and avoiding mistakes can start to dictate how you live.
Why Do We Judge Other People’s Imperfections?
The standards we impose on ourselves can spill over into our expectations of others. If we believe mistakes are unacceptable, we may struggle when someone else makes one.
Sometimes there is resentment underneath: “I work so hard to get everything right. Why aren’t they making the same effort?” Someone else’s more relaxed approach may challenge rules we have spent years obeying.
That is one possible explanation, rather than something we can assume about every critical person. We cannot know what was behind the comment about following me. But there is a useful distinction between questioning an error and dismissing an entire person because they made one. We can expect accuracy, ask questions and challenge information without demanding flawlessness.
The same applies at work and at home. People need to take responsibility for mistakes, but they also need room to acknowledge and correct them.
The Wrap-up
Perfectionism can promise acceptance, control and protection from criticism. Yet no amount of checking or achievement can make us immune to being judged.
You can care about doing things well, learn from feedback and take responsibility when you get something wrong. You can also allow yourself to be a person whose value doesn’t disappear with a mistake.
Perhaps the question to ask is: “What am I afraid this imperfection says about me?” Because that fear may need more attention than the mistake itself.
What Next?
Again, in the extended YouTube version, I also discuss how to loosen the grip of perfectionism. You can watch it here.
If you enjoy my content, I’d love you to subscribe to my YouTube channel. Every like, comment and subscription genuinely helps more people discover my work and enables me to continue creating free content.
If your organisation is looking to develop more confident, psychologically aware leaders, or you’d like to discuss executive coaching, leadership development or a keynote speaker for your next event, I’d love to hear from you. You can contact me at info@jobanks.net.
If there’s a particular workplace, leadership or psychology topic you’d like me to explore in a future article or video, please let me know. I’m always interested in hearing your suggestions.
If you enjoyed this article and want to stay up to date with all the latest news (including new posts and videos), sign up for my weekly newsletter here.
As always, thanks for your continued support.



