Audio Version (10:11)
We’ve all worked with difficult people. The colleague who takes credit for your work. The manager who changes the goalposts. The person who somehow leaves you feeling confused, wrong-footed, or even guilty after a perfectly reasonable conversation.
But every now and then, you come across something more subtle and far more draining. A master manipulator.
These individuals are not always loud or obviously toxic. In fact, many of them are highly likeable on the surface. They can be charming, persuasive, and even admired. That is part of what makes them so effective.
If you have ever walked away from an interaction thinking, “What just happened there?” this one’s for you.
Let’s break down what to look for and, just as importantly, how to trust your instincts when something feels off.
To watch the extended YouTube version of this article, where I also discuss What You Can Do About it, click here.
Signs of a Master Manipulator
They Create Confusion
One of the earliest signs of manipulation is confusion. In my extensive experience of dealing with these personality types, confusion is the No 1 red flag.
You go into a conversation with a clear point or a simple question, and somehow you leave feeling muddled. The focus shifts. The facts get blurred. You may even start questioning your own understanding.
This is not accidental. A master manipulator knows that clarity gives you power. Confusion takes it away. It destabilises you.
You might notice things like:
Conversations going in circles
Questions not being answered directly
Sudden topic changes when accountability is required
Over time, this creates self-doubt. You start second-guessing yourself instead of challenging them.
If you consistently feel confused after interacting with the same person, pay attention. That is data.
They Rewrite Reality
This is often referred to as gaslighting, although in the workplace it can be very subtle.
A manipulator may:
Deny saying something you clearly remember
Claim a decision was agreed when it was not
Reframe events in a way that benefits them
At first, you might assume it is a misunderstanding. Everyone forgets things occasionally. The difference here is consistency. If someone repeatedly alters the narrative to suit themselves, that is not poor memory. That is a strategy.
This can be particularly damaging because it erodes your confidence in your own judgment. You may find yourself keeping emails, making notes, or mentally replaying conversations just to reassure yourself. That is your instinct trying to protect you.
They Use Charm Selectively
Master manipulators are rarely unpleasant all the time. In fact, they are often very good at knowing when to turn on the charm.
They might:
Be warm and engaging in meetings
Build strong relationships with senior people
Publicly praise others… when it suits them
This creates a powerful contrast. When they are difficult, dismissive, or undermining behind the scenes, it becomes harder for others to believe you. After all, “they are always so nice.”
This selective behaviour is not inconsistency. It is control. They are managing how they are perceived and who sees which version of them.
They Play the Victim When Challenged
If you ever try to address their behaviour, watch what happens next.
Instead of engaging with the issue, they may:
Become defensive very quickly
Suggest you are being unfair
Position themselves as the one being attacked
You may even find yourself apologising, despite raising a legitimate concern.
This is a classic manipulation tactic. It shifts the focus away from their behaviour and onto your reaction.
Before you know it, the conversation is no longer about what they did. It is about how you said it, or how it made them feel.
It is subtle, but incredibly effective.
In the next couple of weeks, I’ll be posting an article about a tactic that many toxic personalities use to divert accountability away from them: DARVO – Deny, Attack, Victim Offender. So, make sure you’re subscribed so that you don’t miss it.
They Exploit Your Good Nature
If you are conscientious, empathetic, or a Highly Sensitive Person, you are more likely to be targeted. Not because you are weak, but because you care.
A manipulator will quickly learn:
You do not like conflict
You want to be fair
You are willing to give people the benefit of the doubt
They will use this. They may push boundaries, knowing you are unlikely to challenge them. They may rely on you to pick up extra work. They may appeal to your sense of responsibility or guilt.
Over time, you may find yourself doing more and getting less in return. This is not a coincidence. It is calculated.
This works because most of us expect people to ‘play by the rules’. To behave the same way that we do. To have the same values and concern for others that we do. However, the sad reality is that many people just don’t!
They Take Credit and Deflect Blame
This is one of the more visible behaviours, but it often sits alongside the more subtle ones. A master manipulator will:
Step forward when things go well
Step back when things go wrong
They may present your ideas as their own. Or position themselves as the driving force behind a successful project. When there are issues, however, they are quick to:
Highlight external factors
Point to others’ mistakes
Distance themselves from responsibility
If you notice a pattern where one person consistently comes out looking good regardless of the outcome, look a little closer.
They Create Alliances and Divide Teams
Manipulators rarely operate in isolation. They often build alliances, but not in a healthy, collaborative way.
Instead, they may:
Share selective information
Speak differently about the same situation to different people
Subtly undermine colleagues behind their backs
This creates division. People become unsure of whom to trust. Communication breaks down. Tension increases.
Meanwhile, the manipulator stays at the centre of it all, often appearing helpful or well-connected. It is a clever way of maintaining control without being directly accountable.
Your Body Often Knows Before Your Mind Does
This is the part many people overlook. Before you can logically explain what is happening, you may feel it. You might notice:
A sense of unease before meetings
Feeling drained after interactions
Tightness or tension during conversations
As someone who understands stress responses, you will recognise this as your nervous system picking up on something that is not quite right.
Fight, flight, or freeze does not only show up in obvious physical danger. It can be triggered by psychological threat, too. If your body consistently reacts to a particular person, do not ignore it.
That awareness is one of your greatest assets. If something doesn’t feel right about a person or situation, it’s not! Trust your instincts. They are there for a reason.
The Wrap-up
Master manipulators are not always easy to spot, especially when you are in the middle of it. They rely on confusion, charm, and subtle shifts in power. They exploit good people who want to do the right thing.
But once you start to see the patterns, things become clearer. If something feels off, there is usually a reason.
Trust your instincts. Pay attention to the patterns and give yourself permission to take your own experience seriously.
You are not imagining it, and you can deal with it once you recognise what’s happening.
What Next?
Again to watch the extended YouTube version of this article, where I also discuss What You Can Do About it, click here.
The YouTube algorithm is ruthless at the moment, so if you could please like, comment and subscribe (it’s completely free and you don’t need a Google email address!), I would really appreciate it. Your support helps me get this free content in front of more people.
Without your interaction, videos simply don’t get pushed out by YouTube, and all that hard work goes nowhere!
If there are any subjects you’d like me to cover in upcoming content or if you’d like coaching support with anything I discuss in my videos or articles, please email me at info@jobanks.net.
However, recently, I’ve received many emails and DMs from people asking for my views on their personal/professional situations. Unfortunately, for a number of reasons, I can’t provide individual advice unless you are a client.
As always, thanks for your continued support.
